Don’t Enter a Land of Wonder Looking for Anything Except Things to Make You Wonder More

Posted On November 18, 2009

Filed under Meighan A.

Comments Dropped 3 responses

I was struck by a sudden thought while reading Gabriella’s entry, “Turning Wisdom on Its Head”, and some of the comments she received, that seems to me so very logical and obvious that I can’t believe I didn’t think about it before!

We have all been trying to analyze Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, regardless of having been told that this was originally written as a simple gift for a little girl. Now I see that we can analyze all we wish, maybe come up with some good ideas, opinions, or assumptions, but we can never really know for sure if that was what Carroll had intended for us to see. That is if he even intended for people outside the Liddell family to really understand anything.

First of, Wonderland is a place for wondering. Why on earth do we insist on finding logic and laws in a land for wonder? It’s completely illogical! When you wonder do you consider if what you are wondering is logical? Does it really matter if it is or not? No, because you are wondering and wondering is for processing thoughts and ideas and imagining. If you are wondering nothing you wonder has to make sense or follow laws, it’s just thoughts running about your mind like headless chickens.

For Wonderland to be logical and have reasonable characters would be contrary to its name. Nothing that happens has to make sense or even tie into anything else that happened. If you imagine a White Rabbit and then he becomes a big fat shark that lives on land then that’s perfectly fine! It’s what you wondered so it doesn’t have to follow any law or reason. It just is what it is because that is what you wondered. If anything makes sense then good for you, it’s a rare coincidence.

When you are curious about something you had learned such as…I don’t know, greek mythology for example. Do you think, “Oh, I am going to wonder about this in a logical manner and make sure it all makes sense.” Or do you think “Huh, I rather like that Pegasus creature. I would like to fly around on one.” and forget completely that Pegasus doesn’t exist (at least we don’t have evidence of one) as you wonder about what it would be like to fly around on the back of Pegasus.

Now, before I go off on a tangent and confuse you all with a ‘beat around the bush’ style of getting to my point, I will state it simply. We keep trying to find logic and reason and law in Wonderland. There isn’t any. There shouldn’t be, if there was it wouldn’t be a wonderland. We won’t find it. Unless you are considering the logic of the fact that there is no logic. All we can do in Wonderland is come upon places and people who will make us wonder more. That is why it is a land of wonder.

of course the idea of the story itself can be rationalized; such as Carroll’s intentions, and puns. We can observe symbolism and bring it to each other’s notice, and formulate opinions on what we read, but in the case of Wonderland itself – not Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland but the place- we cannot rationalize anything for sure because we don’t know what was going on in Carroll’s mind.

Advertisements

3 Responses to “Don’t Enter a Land of Wonder Looking for Anything Except Things to Make You Wonder More”

  1. Emma L.

    I completely agree with your thoughts on analyzing Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland.

    Did Carroll even think that his book would be published and read by millions of people all over the world? No one knows. After reading this story and many blogs, do we even know what the definition of logical is anymore? I thought I knew yet many ideas and statements have made me reconsider. There are many questions (that make my brain hurt) that I have pondered for many years that I still don’t absolutely know the answer to. I just have come to the conclusion that it could be one of the world’s mysteries that are meant to be pondered and should not be spent aching days or years on trying to figure out.

    It would be so much easier if Carroll was alive so many of the questions could be answered. Alas, he is not but I guess it’s healthy to wonder and ponder the unimaginable. *wink*

    Feel free to check out my teams blogs http://aliceproject12.wordpress.com/ ! Although I already know you are a big fan of Vivian’s work (:

  2. Alex F.

    Brilliant. Why on earth would someone try to make sense of a place called WONDERland? It sucks all the fun out of it! It was written for a little girl, after all, why should there be any reason to it? I remember when I was reading stories when I was little, and I didn’t care if the answer to all life’s problems was hidden in the text. I wanted to read about a cat making a mess of a house, with Thing 1 and Thing 2 helping with the fun. That’s it. Does it make sense that a talking cat wearing a striped hat suddenly shows up with poofy-haired creatures and messes up your house??? No! But its FUN to read about! So why can’t Wonderland be just like Dr. Seuss’s stories? Just a fun little past-time to amuse a little girl?

    I love this post, thank you Meighan 🙂

  3. Vivian H.

    I love your point stated. There can by no reason or logic in wonderland, because that makes it what it is. Analyses is based on logical reasoning, therefore we cannot truly analyze this piece of literature as we do most other works. Perhaps, the only way we can examine this pecularity is to relate it to what we know, and the “purpose” of Alice’s adventure is to capture the imaginative child like interest of the readers. I believe Alice can be seen either way, because Carroll leaves many of his quotes open ended. We can choose to dig for deeper meanings, or simply enjoy it as a fun children’s tale to read. Great last line: “we cannot rationalize anything for sure because we don’t know what was going on in Carroll’s mind.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s